Law.com reports here on an oral argument before the 11th Circuit in yet another case addressing the fallout of the Florida Supreme Court’s Engle decision. As we have noted in prior posts, Engle reversed a $145 billion punitive damages award in a class action brought by smokers, but determined that certain factual findings could be “retained” for future litigation. Now the 11th Circuit is trying to figure out what effect that decision has in federal court.

Related posts:

Florida Jury Awards $244 Million in Punitive Damages to SmokerFlorida Jury Awards $25 Million in Punitive Damages to Smoker’s Widow

“Smokers, tobacco, both winners in early Engle cases”

Jury Rules For Plaintiff in First Phase of Retrial After Reversal of $145 Billion Punitive Damages Award

After Reversal of $145 Billion Class Action Punitive Damages Award, Florida Smokers Seek Punitive Damages in Individual Suits

Plaintiffs’ Attorneys Win $218 Million Fee Award for Helping Obtain a Punitive Damages Verdict that Was Reversed on Appeal